« * K New Scientist

Big tech may finally face legal consequences for AI’s actions

Jacob Aron - 2026-11-19 19:32 UTC

rogue AI systems run amok”.

Advertisement

if( window?.adverts?.addToArray ) {

window.adverts.addToArray( {

"pos": "mid-article-slot"

} );

}

Ever since the Hugging Face attack occurred, I have struggled to understand why OpenAI has yet to face legal consequences for what would seem to be a crime – unauthorised computer access under the US Computer Fraud and Abuse Act – if conducted by a human. So far, the legal answer to this seems to be a lack of intent, which the law requires, and it remains an untested legal question whether an AI can have intent , according to an analysis by US firm Ballard Spahr. California is instead bringing a civil suit, alleging that OpenAI created a risk to public safety and violated the state’s Unfair Competition Law, which prohibits harmful or fraudulent business practices even when there is no intent to deceive.

OpenAI has objected to the lawsuit. “This lawsuit appears to single out OpenAI over a challenge that’s been identified by every major AI lab,” said OpenAI spokesperson Drew Pusateri . As legal defences go, “everyone is doing it” doesn’t seem like a very good one to me, but that will be for the courts to decide.

What is clear is that we need an agreed understanding of liability when it comes to AI, but what I don’t think we need are special AI laws when our existing ones work just fine. For example, in 2024, Air Canada was held liable for

Page 2 of 5

# Next pagePrevious page3 Next storyBack to the list

Web address: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2599970-big-tech-may-finally-face-legal-consequences…

All feeds
☆ Save to home · 0 Home · Find · Games · Chat · AI · Setup