New ScientistBig tech may finally face legal consequences for AI’s actions
Jacob Aron - 2026-11-19 19:32 UTC
misleading information given to a customer by its AI chatbot. A tribunal ruled that Air Canada had effectively tried to argue that the chatbot was a legally separate entity that it was not responsible for – an argument that did not wash.
In my view, any similar claims that AI can have its own legal agency should be dismissed. The argument that an AI is a legal actor serves AI companies in two ways, neither of which benefits society at large. The first is that it attempts to swerve responsibility, while the second is that it adds to the story of AI being an all-powerful, unknowable being. That second story is at the heart of the current AI revolution, but it isn’t one we have to listen to.
Read more
How preppers plan to save us if the whole internet collapses
I prefer a different argument. For the past year or so, Arvind Narayanan and Sayash Kapoor at Princeton University have put forward the idea of “ AI as Normal Technology ” – transformative, yes, in the same way as the internet or electricity, but not something that requires re-engineering the ordinary functions of society. As a normal technology, normal laws can apply. Writing about the Hugging Face attack earlier this year, the pair said that “AI companies should be liable for what their agents do” and, like Bonta, blame OpenAI’s internal culture and lack of human oversight for the incident.
The most high-profile example
Page 3 of 5
# Next pagePrevious page3 Next storyBack to the listWeb address: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2599970-big-tech-may-finally-face-legal-consequences…
All feeds