New ScientistBig tech may finally face legal consequences for AI’s actions
Jacob Aron - 2026-11-19 19:32 UTC
of existing laws being applied to AI companies is a class-action lawsuit against Anthropic , alleging that the firm used pirated copies of books to train its Claude AI models. Anthropic settled, and is now in the process of paying out to affected authors from a $1.5 billion fund. The wider question of whether training an AI on copyrighted material is illegal or counts as fair use remains open, and I really can’t believe that, four years after the launch of ChatGPT, we don’t yet have an answer to what is probably one of the most fundamental legal disputes of our time. OpenAI has previously said it would be “ impossible ” to create the kind of AI we have now without using copyrighted material, so this is an existential question for the AI firms.
Existing laws can also be tweaked to make it clear that they apply to AI. The European Union has done just that, updating a 1985 consumer rights directive to produce the 2024 Product Liability Directive , which explicitly makes it clear that software, including artificial intelligence, is a product and that people writing software are liable for any defects. The law doesn’t come into force until 9 December, when EU members must implement it, and it remains to be seen how it might be used against AI companies.
In other words, we don’t have to try to send a computer to jail. We’ve got humans who should be liable instead. As Bonta says,
Page 4 of 5
# Next pagePrevious page3 Next storyBack to the listWeb address: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2599970-big-tech-may-finally-face-legal-consequences…
All feeds